Keep the Diff Premium Download
All articles

The no spend challenge, without the streak that ruins it

By , who built Keep the Diff

A no spend challenge is simple to describe and hard to finish. Pick a period, buy nothing beyond essentials, and see it through. The internet is full of thirty day versions, and most of the people who start one do not get to the end.

The usual explanation is discipline. The real cause is the scoreboard.

How most no spend challenges are scored

Nearly every no spend challenge app, printable and tracker works the same way: a run of consecutive clean days. Day one, day two, day three. Buy a coffee on day twelve and the count goes back to zero.

Look carefully at what that number measures: whether you have failed yet. How much you saved, how many good decisions you made and whether the month went well are all invisible to it. It is a counter that can only rise until it is destroyed.

And the longer it rises the more it costs to lose, so the thing that was supposed to encourage you gradually turns into something you are frightened of. That is loss aversion doing exactly what it always does, aimed at you by a tool that is supposed to be on your side.

The predictable failure

Eleven good days. Then day twelve goes wrong, because days do. You are at a station, or a friend is visiting, or you are simply tired.

The counter resets. Eleven days of real decisions, worth real money, vanish from the screen as though they never happened. The tracker now says zero, which is the same thing it said before you started.

Most people do not begin again, and that is a sensible response to a scoreboard that just told them eleven days of effort were worth nothing. If eleven days and zero days display identically, the tracker has thrown away the only information that mattered.

Score the money

Here is the alternative, and it is a small change with a large consequence. Count the money you did not spend.

Each time you decide against something, record what you were ready to spend and what you actually spent. The difference is added to a running total. That is the score.

Now work through the same twelve days. Eleven decisions, adding up to, say, two hundred and forty dollars. On day twelve you buy the coffee. What happens to the two hundred and forty?

Nothing. There is no entry that day, so the total stays exactly where it was. It does not reset, it does not go down, and there is no red number, because a total of money saved has no way to express disapproval. The lowest it can ever read is zero.

Why this changes who can finish

A streak challenge is only winnable by someone who is perfect for the whole period. That is a small group, and most of them were going to be fine anyway.

A money total is winnable by everybody, because every single good decision counts and no bad one erases any of them. Somebody who slips four times in a month still finishes with a real number, made of real decisions, and the four slips simply leave no mark.

A money total also fixes the restart problem. Under a streak, coming back on day twenty means starting from zero with nineteen days of nothing behind you. Under a total, coming back on day twenty means adding to a number that is still sitting there waiting.

Partial wins, which strict challenges cannot express at all

Partial wins are the second thing streaks get wrong. In a no spend challenge every day is binary: clean or ruined. There is no way to record spending forty dollars when you were about to spend ninety.

But that is a fifty dollar decision, and it is the most common kind. Choosing the cheaper option, the smaller size, the matinee, the store brand, the repair instead of the replacement. A binary tracker calls all of that a failed day. A money total calls it fifty dollars, because that is what it is.

Over a month the gap is large. For most people the partial decisions outnumber the outright refusals, so a tracker that cannot see them is missing the majority of the behavior it claims to measure.

How to run a no spend month this way

  1. Do not set rules about categories. The value is in noticing decisions. Rules create arguments with yourself and the arguments are what you quit over.
  2. Log the ones you notice. Two or three a day is normal. You will not catch everything and it does not matter, because there is no perfect score to protect.
  3. Write the real number. What you had actually accepted paying, which is often less than the most expensive version you could justify. An inflated total is a total you stop believing, and once you stop believing it you stop logging.
  4. Look at the total once a week. Daily is too fine a grain to show a trend and turns into the same anxious checking a streak produces.
  5. Move the money at the end of the week to savings if you want the total sitting in an account. The total is the exact figure to transfer to savings.

What you have at the end

A streak challenge ends in one of two states: a badge, or nothing. A money total ends in an amount, and it ends in an amount whether the month went perfectly or not.

That amount is also the honest answer to the question people actually want answered: "how much did this get me?"

Keep the Diff scores no spend challenges this way: it counts money kept, has no streak anywhere in it, and counts partial decisions properly. It is free on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, Windows, Linux and Android, with no bank connection and no account needed. There is a longer explanation here, or you can try the scoring in your browser first.

More on this